Improving Information Literacy Instruction with a Graphic Organizer

An assignment that can transform InfoLit from keyword searches to critical thought

For academic librarians, one of the most important pathways to engaging with students runs through faculty. Collaborations between librarians and faculty not only bolster the library’s standing but also greatly enrich students’ education and invigorate the academic community as a whole. ACRL has dedicated a two-volume series to librarian-faculty collaborations: Faculty and Librarian Partnerships, Volume 1: Information Literacy and Faculty Empowerment and Faculty and Librarian Partnerships, Volume 2: Customized Program Support, both edited by Amy Dye-Reeves and Erica Watson. Across 36 combined chapters, these volumes offer grounded advice—from planning to implementation—on librarian-faculty partnerships.

Reprinted below in full under a CC BY-NC SA license is a chapter taken from the first volume, originally published as “Beyond Keywords: Encouraging Disciplinary Faculty to Teach Information Literacy Through a Graphic Organizer.” Authors Pamela E. Mann and Samantha L. Elliott offer a Graphic Organizer assignment that presses students to evaluate texts critically, going beyond mere database searching to carefully parse and consider what they find, and offers faculty members a thoughtful heuristic for teaching InfoLit skills to students.

📙 Learn more and order a copy of Faculty and Librarian Partnerships from ACRL.


Beyond Keywords: Encouraging Disciplinary Faculty to Teach Information Literacy Through a Graphic Organizer

By Pamela E. Mann and Samantha L. Elliott

Literature Review

Information Access is not Comprehension

Current undergraduate students have always had wide access to information through technology, including scholarly research. However, access does not mean that students have the disciplinary knowledge to use sources in a meaningful way. Indeed, the literature indicates that K12 students have a wide range of experiences in information literacy before reaching college and that the use of digital technology does not translate to knowledge of educational technology.1,2,3 “When students are new to a topic, they don’t often know what information is important and how different pieces of information are related to each other.”4 While able to compile quotes and facts from other sources,5,6 students learn to identify scholarly articles by their surface features with a “focus on externalities.”7 Dominated by keyword searches, this also leads students to find sources that match an existing idea rather than reading and using sources to answer a question.

Information Literacy: Faculty, Student, and Librarian Epistemologies

In our experience, librarians are often stuck between faculty epistemologies about scholarly work and undergraduate students’ learning needs. Faculty understand “by virtue of training that in a particular way of knowing, superior to and more rigorous than other forms of information. Scholarship is analytical, critical, and bound by certain methodological and ethical conventions that make it trustworthy.”8 This knowledge is socially constructed during graduate school. However, “[f]aculty members’ implicit faith in scholarly expertise can be at odds with [the] undergraduate experience.”9 Instructors often assume that the scholarly conventions they learned in graduate school are inherently understood by undergraduate students. Therefore, faculty valuation of and emphasis on scholarly articles at every level in undergraduate education, from first year to senior year, risks perpetuating surface-level understanding of scholarly sources, unless sufficient scaffolding is present to guide students through their use.

When asked to utilize scholarly sources, undergraduate students focus less on the source content and more on the assignment criteria (e.g., a certain number of peer-reviewed references). This comes at the expense of “the conceptual understandings that organize many other concepts and ideas about information, research, and scholarship into a coherent whole.”10 This is particularly apparent with undergraduate students who, early in their college careers, lack disciplinary knowledge. “When students are new to a topic, they often don’t know what information is important and how different pieces of information are related to each other … even the strongest freshmen writers were not able to stand back and offer overarching claims and interpretations.”11 “[A]s novices, most [first year students] have neither the tools to pry open their sources nor the familiarity with them to ask ‘why’ questions instead of ‘what’ questions. They tend to describe and summarize their sources,”12 approximating scholarly writing. Databases facilitate this by labeling and filtering articles as “peer reviewed,” and aggregators such as Google and Credo Reference provide search engines that guarantee certain sources are acceptable for college research. When students get results from keyword searches, too often, the source’s identity is more important than its content.

Disciplinary faculty and librarians often have divergent views on what constitutes information literacy. The Association of College and Research Libraries (ACRL)13 defines information literacy as “a cluster of interconnected core concepts, with flexible options for implementation, rather than on a set of standards or learning outcomes, or any prescriptive enumeration of skills,”14 and yet librarians are often asked by disciplinary faculty to teach specific skills such as database searching and citation formatting as information literacy instruction. Librarians who say yes to database sessions without negotiating believe it is a way to serve students and faculty. These service-oriented librarians want the professor to know they can be helpful and rationalize the demonstrations. “It’s the students who will suffer if I don’t do it. Even if they get something little out of it, it’s worth it. Students will know that the library is a friendly place.”15 This has led to students receiving repeated information literacy sessions covering the same topic, reinforcing their perception that information literacy is only about database searching. Despite a long history of these tensions between faculty and librarians,16 survey data published in 202217 suggest that the need to say “yes” to these requests from faculty is still an issue for librarians and has been a recurring problem on our campus.

Librarians as Faculty Developers

Librarians closely collaborate with both faculty and students; they have a unique perspective on what students find challenging about academic assignments and have a vast supply of important information to share with instructors. However, many faculty do not consider librarians to be teaching experts, in part due to a lack of specific disciplinary knowledge.18,19,20 Collaborations between librarians and teaching and learning centers can formally elevate librarians’ expertise when working with faculty, fostering partnerships and a shared vision of student learning.21,22,23,24,25

Graphic Organizers as Information Literacy Tools

Graphic organizers are used in a variety of disciplines to visualize the learning process.26,27,28 While most instructors are familiar with concept mapping or Venn diagrams in this context, graphic organizers can take many forms.29 Within information literacy, specifically, graphic organizers are among the best practices for student learning30 and can be used to provide structure for students’ writing and research, starting with asking good questions and approximating scholarly writing.31,32

To better address undergraduate student needs around information literacy and scholarly sources, we adapted an existing graphic organizer activity, which was originally designed by author Mann as an in-class activity to provide structure for students’ writing and research. It is a low-stakes activity that prompts students to go beyond finding quotes and summarizing, emphasizing identifying claims, asking questions, and reflecting on what they found. It also encourages students to choose topics within the course that interest them. “When faculty construct writing assignments that allow students to bring their interests into a course, they say to their students, ‘This is the disciplinary field and you are part of it.’”33

Institutional Context

Institutional Demographics and Context

The authors are both employed at St. Mary’s College of Maryland (SMCM), which is a small public liberal arts college enrolling approximately 1,500 students and with a faculty-to-student ratio of ten to one for the 2022–2023 academic year.34 Faculty from multiple departments and programs participated in the general education writing-intensive courses (CORE101 and CORE301) described in this chapter35 (see appendix A). CORE 101 or CORE 301 are among the first courses that a student takes at SMCM upon matriculation as part of the SMCM LEAD Curriculum.36

Physical Proximity: The Genesis of a Powerful Collaboration

In 2019, St. Mary’s College of Maryland (SMCM) created the Center for Inclusive Teaching and Learning (CITL),37 a teaching and learning center with dedicated physical space for faculty development on campus. The planning committee investigated many models of such centers at other institutions, and one aspect became quite clear: many teaching and learning center spaces were either originally associated with libraries or specifically moved to be library-adjacent. Based upon these findings, the Hilda C. Landers Library38 was chosen as the location for the CITL at SMCM. In our experience, this proximity has led to fruitful faculty development collaborations among academic librarians, CITL staff, and disciplinary teaching faculty.

Initially, formal collaborations between SMCM librarians and CITL consisted mostly of single, standalone, one-hour workshops on information literacy topics. As with other CITL offerings, these workshops were well attended, and attendees provided positive feedback. However, the challenge of reaching a wider audience remained: instructor requests for SMCM librarian collaborations continued to indicate that the best practices around information literacy were not being followed. This assumes that SMCM librarians are invited into the classroom at all—information literacy sessions were commonly cut due to limited in-class time and instructor assumptions of students’ prior knowledge. Librarians’ participation as CITL workshop leaders on topics such as critical information literacy, the ACRL Framework for Information Literacy for Higher Education, and engaged learning established SMCM librarians as credible faculty developers in information literacy. It was in these small-group, active-learning sessions that the SMCM librarians’ authority was constructed. SMCM librarians were seen as experts in their discipline and valued partners in student learning.

Levers of Institutional Change

It became clear that intensive professional development of faculty was required for effective information literacy pedagogy. However, staffing shortages in both CITL and the library meant that we did not have enough people to take a fully hands-on approach, which would be the norm at a small liberal arts college. Additionally, a dramatic change in course scheduling threatened to reduce the amount of time librarians had contact with students within the classroom, either through the shortened class times or instructors cutting librarian class visits due to concerns about content coverage. Alternative approaches were needed if we were to not only keep our current audience but also expand our reach on campus to properly integrate information literacy across the curriculum.

To address these goals and limitations, the authors (Pamela E. Mann and Samantha L. Elliott) met to discuss options for asynchronous delivery and deeper connection with information literacy concepts. We began with an existing audience–faculty development training within the SMCM CORE 101/301 sequence, a writing-intensive seminar course taken by all first-year (101) or transfer students (301). These general education courses are taught by faculty across all departments on campus, with a thematic approach to learning college-level writing, critical thinking, and other foundational skills.39 While collaborating with disciplinary faculty in CORE101 and 301, SMCM librarians took this opportunity to approach students as “novice experts”40 who were learning how to “write information literacy.”41

The challenge, therefore, was coordinating disciplinary faculty to provide consistent instruction in rhetoric and information literacy (see appendix A). Thus, we developed an online professional development module that could be used independently or in concert with in-person training to explicitly define information literacy as it relates to student experiences, showcase an activity that centers student process in finding and using sources, and guide assessment practices using the supplied rubric (appendix C), including norming with others.

Our Solution: Adaptation of the Graphic Organizer

Creation of the Graphic Organizer activity by SMCM librarians as a tool for information literacy came about after a 2016 assessment of final papers within the CORE 101/301 seminars indicated that students fell below the target metric for all information literacy objectives.42 Upon further analysis of source use and through conversations with faculty, it became evident that students were using keywords and skimming to find source material and then misusing information from source texts to support the claims in their papers. SMCM librarians then used these findings to create a graphic organizer to directly meet these learning needs (see appendix B).

In the 2019 fall semester, the library assessed the CORE 101/301 courses using an early version of the Graphic Organizer activity. We scored thirty-one classes and 400 graphic organizers. Students in both CORE101 and 301 underperformed on the Graphic Organizer assessment in 2019, with CORE 301 students meeting the benchmarked score of 3 in only one category, accessing information, and with CORE 101 students not far behind at 2.88 (see table 1). This indicates that the Graphic Organizer is able to measure student learning in a similar way to the earlier librarian analyses of final exam papers in 2016.43

 Access InformationIdentify Key ConceptsArticulates QuestionsExplains Relevance
CORE 30131.922.372.33
CORE 1012.881.922.182.15
Table 1. An assessment of student learning using the Graphic Organizer rubric.

The current version of the Graphic Organizer activity has been further modified based upon committee review and alignment with current information literacy objectives within the SMCM CORE 101/301 sequence: an introduction to research as iterative and inquiry-based and to rhetorical evaluation of information. We emphasize this within the professional development module: the Graphic Organizer activity itself emphasizes research as inquiry, and our evaluation session uses a rhetorical triangle that aligns with the recommended approach by our Writing and Speaking Center faculty developers. Both are designed to integrate with the work and themes of any disciplinary-based CORE 101/301 course.

The Graphic Organizer activity became the nexus of our efforts within the information literacy professional development module for multiple reasons: faculty who adopted the activity were usually enthusiastic about its ability to discern both the searching and use of source materials. Many saw connections to use it with upper-division students as well. For example, author Elliott successfully used it within an upper-division biology class, where it helped students refine their search terms to locate not just appropriate source material but also identify highly relevant source material versus tangential information. For others, it gave direct evidence of the disconnect between finding and using sources, which provided buy-in for further information literacy training and instruction. Finally, our redesign promoted an active-learning activity that could be adapted for either inside or outside of class time, which was attractive to instructors grappling with our new course scheduling.

The Professional Development Training Module

Background Reading: What’s the Problem?

This section grounds the reasoning behind what students really struggle with in terms of information literacy and helps broaden instructor understanding of information literacy beyond the superficial. This includes information literacy concepts both librarians and teaching faculty have observed students struggle with and helps broaden instructor understanding of information literacy beyond identifying the difference between scholarly versus popular sources and how to use a database. We are currently using “Reading in the Age of Distrust”44 as an introductory reading to situate the need for explicit information literacy pedagogy and encourage instructors to think about transparency when creating assignments.

The Graphic Organizer Activity: The Why, Who, and When?

This section situates the graphic organizer activity in terms of why it is useful, how students may benefit from its use, and when during the writing and research process it can be used to full advantage. In this, we emphasize its use within the process of writing and identify multiple ways in which it could be scaffolded within an assignment. This is the brainstorming component of the module, which allows instructors to imagine how the assignment could be integrated into their curriculum based upon their learning outcomes.

The Graphic Organizer activity can be adapted to different audiences and purposes and used more than once in a given class. The emphasis in the Core Seminars, both First Year and Transfer, is cultivating inquiry through exploration and discovery. Students read and write to learn about a topic and situate it in the larger conversation. The training module promotes the use of credible, non-scholarly sources to encourage students’ engagement with the topic by meeting them where they are. The writing emphasis for the Core Seminars is rhetorical, and both the writing and information literacy sessions use the rhetorical triangle45 as a framing device with scholarly sources contextualized as a form of rhetorical writing rather than the only valid genre.

The Graphic Organizer Activity: The What and How?

This section details what the assignment looks like to students and how an instructor can integrate it into a classroom session. This is the true “plug and play” component of the module, which gives instructors the tools they need to use the activity, including the Graphic Organizer itself (appendix B).

Assessment

This section explains the associated Graphic Organizer rubric (appendix C), which allows instructors to assess student learning. This could be used as a mechanism to grade an assignment or to assess learning outcomes as part of a larger course, program, or institutional assessment scheme. We include sample student work for instructors to practice using the rubric beforehand, as well as a mechanism to norm with others, if such effort is desired across course sections or for program/institutional assessment. While provided as an online module, the authors feel that this section of the module is likely best done as a synchronous discussion, if time and resources allow.

Deeper Reading (optional)

This section provides key sources, such as the ACRL Framework,46 that instructors may be interested in reading further but are not strictly necessary to complete the module.

Field Testing

As described earlier, a subset of librarians began using and assessing the Graphic Organizer in the fall of 2018. College-wide assessment of information literacy in 2019 increased its use to all five academic librarians, ultimately resulting in a norming process for the associated rubric, which led to revisions as discussions revealed ways to strengthen the assessment and promote consensus. The current version is the fourth iteration.

Authors Mann and Elliott then created the online module described above and piloted it with nine instructors and one faculty developer during the spring 2023 CORE101/103 professional development retreat. Discussion of the background reading revealed the following themes that resonated with faculty: skimming rather than deep reading; student difficulty identifying the main ideas, claims and arguments; reading on digital devices versus physical copies; the need for scaffolding at all levels of undergraduate education (from first-year to senior capstone); and the reluctance of students to engage in information considered biased.

The faculty reported that the professional development module was easy to work through asynchronously. Questions primarily focused on the mechanics of the activity: Should students use the same source to practice using the Graphic Organizer? Should instructors use it in class or assign it as homework? These questions were anticipated as they are up to instructor discretion. The idea of using the Graphic Organizer at different stages of the semester or the project was readily accepted. Some faculty really liked the idea of using the activity early on to assess student competency before starting a research project, while others focused on using the Graphic Organizer within the research project itself. The feedback and comments led us to create an FAQ to address comments and concerns.

Despite the background reading addressing how gatekeeping of information has changed in the digital age with the collapse of traditional academic publishing, instructor pushback about using non-academic sources remained, even for first-semester students.

Conclusion, Future Expansion, and Recommendations

Faculty professional development in higher education has turned to micro-credentialing as a way to assess instructor learning, as it changes the emphasis from participation to outcomes-driven assessment.47,48 As defined by McCullough et al.,49 micro-credentials are certificates and/or digital badges that can be scaled based on instructor experience and depth of knowledge (e.g., beginner-intermediate-advanced). These programs curate a series of professional development opportunities with multiple modalities and entry points,50 providing increased outreach and engagement.51,52 In-depth faculty development opportunities, such as those involved with certificates or digital badges, are more likely to promote change in instructor habits.53,54,55

The training module about the Graphic Organizer activity is the first element within a larger project to create an intensive information literacy professional development certificate. This certificate will explicitly expand the use of the Graphic Organizer activity beyond the CORE101/301 sequence, encourage instructors to consider the scaffolding of information literacy across the departmental curriculum, and provide opportunities to specialize based on instructor interests. The certificate will intentionally focus on the student process, rather than the final product, and on using assessments that support inclusive teaching practices. We also provide areas of choice and specialization for faculty to best tailor the certificate to their own pedagogical goals. We believe that faculty who complete the certificate program will have a better understanding of key information literacy concepts and approaches and will be less likely to see skills like database searching and citing sources as the primary role of information literacy.

Altogether, these choices allowed us to leverage existing partnerships to shore up information literacy professional development to faculty in a variety of disciplines, thus training individuals within multiple departments and programs. By altering an existing exercise, we addressed faculty concerns about class time and provided an out-of-class activity for students that met “engaged learning” criteria within the curriculum. We also maintained the crucial first-year exposure of students to librarians (and hopefully the associated learning gains) while also emphasizing the usefulness of the graphic organizer in more advanced classes.

Acknowledgments

The authors would like to acknowledge the multiple faculty members involved in the CORE101 and CORE 301 writing-intensive seminar training, especially the 2023 cohort and its facilitator, Dr. Brian O’Sullivan (professor of English), for providing feedback on the online training module. Many individuals helped in the development of the original graphic organizer activity, especially Associate Professor of Psychology Dr. James Mantell and SMCM librarians William Crowell, Kent Randell, Jillian Sandy, and Amanda VerMeu-len. Their feedback led to multiple iterations of the Graphic Organizer and its rubric and led to its current version in this chapter.

Appendix A

DISCIPLINES REPRESENTED IN FACULTY DEVELOPMENT TRAINING FOR CORE 101/301

  • Anthropology
  • Art
  • Biochemistry
  • Biology
  • Chemistry
  • Educational Studies
  • English
  • History
  • International Languages and Cultures
  • Mathematics
  • Music
  • Neuroscience
  • Philosophy
  • Psychology
  • Religious Studies
  • Theater

Appendix B

GRAPHIC ORGANIZER WORKSHEET

TOPIC:

NAME:

BACKGROUND READING: Not every source you read will be a source you cite. As you read your article take notes in each of the following categories.

Information source (citation). Provide enough information for someone to find it.Identify the author’s main ideas, arguments or claims. Identify critical or key concepts related to your topic.Ask Questions. State points of confusion or conflict after reading the source. What else do you want/need to know?Reflect on how the source might (or might not) contribute to your knowledge of the topic.
 









   

Your professor’s name:

Appendix C

GRAPHIC ORGANIZER RUBRIC

 1234
Accesses Information source(s).Does not provide enough information for rater to verify source OR student retrieved no information.     0Retrieves information that is not related to the topic.           0Retrieves at least one information source related to the topic.         0Retrieved more than one information source from a variety of information tools. (Google, Credo, subject encyclopedias.) 0
Identifies key concepts from the information source(s).Does not provide enough information for rater to verify source OR does not identify key concepts based on the information source. 0Identifies at least one key concept in depth OR determines concepts on a surface level (Facts, names. dates, etc.)   0Can identify multiple key concepts based on at least one information source(s). (Beyond surface level)   0Begins to connect key concepts or terms with the larger issues.         0
Articulates questions from the information source(s).Does not articulate questions based on the information source.Articulates questions on a surface level (Facts, identification, asks closed questions.)Articulates a question that builds on previously Identified concepts or questions as well as additional surface level questions.Articulates multiple questions that build on previously identified concepts or questions.
0000
Explains the relevance
of the information source(s). (How might they use the information?)
Does not explain why the source is relevant or how they might use it.Does not explain the relevance of the source beyond “it supports my research or topic.”Begins to connect key concepts with questions and highlights information and/or questions they want more information about.References key concepts and questions. Intentionally identifies relationships between different information source(s). concepts and questions.
0000

Notes

  1. Laura Saunders, Jenny Severyn, and Jes Caron, “Don’t They Teach That in High School? Examining the High School to College Information Literacy Gap,” Library & Information Science Research 39, no. 4 (2017): 276–83.
  2. Wan Ng, “Can We Teach Digital Natives Digital Literacy?,” Computers & Education 59, no. 3 (2012): 1065–78.
  3. Joyce Kasman Valenza et al., “First Years’ Information Literacy Backpacks: What’s Already Packed or Not Packed?,” The Journal of Academic Librarianship 48, no. 4 (2022): 102566.
  4. Nancy Sommers and Laura Saltz, “The Novice as Expert: Writing the Freshman Year,” College Composition and Communication (2004): 124–49.
  5. Glenda Insua, Catherine Lantz, and Annie Armstrong, “Navigating Roadblocks: First-Year Writing Challenges Through the Lens of the ACRL Framework,” Communications in Information Literacy 12, no. 2 (2018), https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1205064.pdf.
  6. Bailey Herrmann, “Writing as an Exploration: Rethinking the Research Paper,” The Wisconsin English Journal 54, no. 2: 49–51.
  7. Barbara Fister, “The Social Life of Knowledge,” Not Just Where to Click, 87, https://barbarafister.net/ SocialLife.pdf.
  8. Fister, “The Social Life of Knowledge,” 87.
  9. Ibid.
  10. Framework for Information Literacy for Higher Education, Association of College and Research Libraries (ACRL), 2016, https://www.ala.org/acrl/standards/ilframework.
  11. Sommers and Saltz, “The Novice as Expert,” 124–49.
  12. Ibid.
  13. Association of College & Research Libraries (ACRL), https://www.ala.org/acrl/.
  14. Framework, ACRL.
  15. Yvonne Nalani Meulemans and Allison Carr, “Not at Your Service: Building Genuine Faculty-Librarian Partnerships,” Reference Services Review 41, no. 1 (2013): 80–90.
  16. Rebecca S. Albitz, “The What and Who of Information Literacy and Critical Thinking in Higher Education,” portal: Libraries and the Academy 7, no. 1 (2007): 97–109.
  17. Lisa Becksford, “Instruction Librarians’ Perceptions of the Faculty–Librarian Relationship,” Communications in Information Literacy 16(2) (2022).
  18. Karla Fribley, Jason M. Vance, and Justin G. Gardner, “Academic Librarians and Campus-Wide Faculty Development: A National Survey,” portal: Libraries and the Academy 21, no. 2 (2021): 253–74.
  19. Jody Condit Fagan, Hillary Ostermiller, Elizabeth Price, and Lara Sapp, “Librarian, Faculty, and Student Perceptions of Academic Librarians: Study Introduction and Literature Review,” New Review of Academic Librarianship 27, no. 1 (2021): 38–75.
  20. Becksford, “Instruction Librarians’ Perceptions.”
  21. Rachel Fundator and Clarence Maybee, “Academic Librarians as Informed Learning Developers,” in Informed Learning Applications: Insights from Research and Practice (Leeds, UK: Emerald Publishing Limited, 2019), 81–94.
  22. Karla Fribley, Jason M. Vance, and Justin G. Gardner, “Academic Librarians and Campus-Wide Faculty Development: A National Survey,” portal: Libraries and the Academy 21, no. 2 (2021): 253–74.
  23. Melissa Bowles-Terry and Karen Sobel, “Librarians as Faculty Developers: Competencies and Recommendations,” The Journal of Academic Librarianship 48, no. 1 (2022): 102474.
  24. Michael Flierl, Clarence Maybee, and Rachel Fundator, “Academic Librarians’ Experiences as Faculty Developers: A Phenomenographic Study,” Communications in Information Literacy 13, no. 2 (2019): 184–204.
  25. Misa Mi, “Expanding Librarian Roles Through a Librarian Initiated and Facilitated Faculty Learning Community,” Journal of Library Administration 55, no. 1 (2015): 24–40.
  26. Canan Nakiboğlu and Nuri Nakiboğlu, “Views of prospective chemistry teachers on the use of graphic organizers supported with interactive PowerPoint presentation technology in teaching electrochemistry concepts,” International Journal of Physics and Chemistry Education 13, no. 3 (2021): 47–63.
  27. Ferit Kilickaya, “Review of Studies on Graphic Organizers and Language Learner Performance,” Online Submission 23 (2019): 6–11.
  28. Bench G. Fabros and Edwin D. Ibañez, “Effectiveness of Utilizing Graphic Organizers in Improving Conceptual Understanding towards Operations of Fractions among Teachers,” International Journal of Instruction 16, no. 1 (2023).
  29. Jennifer D. Green and Beth Dillard, “Scaffolding the Scaffold: Creating Graphic Organizers to Support Your Students’ Learning,” Transformative Dialogues: Teaching and Learning Journal 14, no. 2 (2021).
  30. Mandi Goodsett, “Assessing the Potential for Critical Thinking Instruction in Information Literacy Online Learning Objects Using Best Practices,” Communications in Information Literacy 14, no. 2 (2020): 227–54.
  31. Sommers and Saltz, “The Novice as Expert,” 124–49.
  32. Fister, “The Social Life of Knowledge,” 87.
  33. Sommers and Saltz, “The Novice as Expert,” 124–49.
  34. SMCM Quick Facts 2022-2023, accessed November 30, 2023, https://www.smcm.edu/ir/ about-st-marys/quick-facts/.
  35. SMCM CORE Seminars, accessed November 30, 2023, https://www.smcm.edu/newstudents/ core-seminars/.
  36. SMCM LEAD Curriculum, accessed November 30, 2023, https://www.smcm.edu/academics/lead/.
  37. SMCM Center for Inclusive Teaching and Learning, accessed November 30, 2023, https://www.smcm. edu/citl/.
  38. SMCM Hilda C. Landers Library, accessed November 30, 2023, https://library.smcm.edu/.
  39. SMCM CORE Seminars.
  40. Sommers and Saltz, “The Novice as Expert,” 124–49.
  41. Karen Gocsik, Laura R. Braunstein, and E. Tobery Cynthia, “Approximating the University: The Information Literacy Practices of Novice Researchers,” Information Literacy: Research and Collaboration Across Disciplines (2017): 163–84.
  42. Veronica Arellano Douglas and Celia E. Rabinowitz, “Examining the Relationship Between Faculty-Librarian Collaboration and First-Year Students’ Information Literacy Abilities,” College & Research Libraries 77, no. 2 (2016): 144–63.
  43. Douglas and Rabinowitz, “Examining the Relationship,” 144–63.
  44. Alison Head, “Reading in the Age of Distrust,” Project Information Literacy, 2021, https:// projectinfolit.org/pubs/provocation-series/essays/reading-in-the-age-of-distrust.html.
  45. “Handouts and Tips: Rhetorical Awareness,” SMCM Writing and Speaking Center, https://www.smcm. edu/writingcenter/handouts-and-tips/.
  46. Framework, ACRL.
  47. Melissa Tooley and Joseph Hood, “Moving toward Competency-Based Professional Learning,” State Education Standard 21, no. 2 (2021): 35.
  48. Melissa Tooley and Joseph Hood, “Harnessing Micro-Credentials for Teacher Growth: A National Review of Early Best Practices,” New America (2021).
  49. Heather McCullough and Kim Buch, “Using Certificates to Engage Faculty in Professional Development,” Current Issues in Education 21, no. 2 (Special Issue) (2020).
  50. Kate Z. Williams, Lauren E. Margulieux, and G. David Lawrence, “Teaching Certificate Redesign: Making a Flexible Program for Future Faculty,” To Improve the Academy: A Journal of Educational Development 39, no. 2 (2020).
  51. Lauren Acree, “Seven Lessons Learned from Implementing Micro-credentials,” NC State University, 2016, https://fi.ncsu.edu/news/seven-lessons-learned-from-implementing-micro-credentials/.
  52. Tiffany Hunt, Richard Carter, Ling Zhang, and Sohyun Yang, “Micro-credentials: The Potential of Personalized Professional Development,” Development and Learning in Organizations: An International Journal 34, no. 2 (2020): 33–35.
  53. Andrew C. Porter, Michael S. Garet, Laura Desimone, Kwang Suk Yoon, and Beatrice F. Birman, “Does Professional Development Change Teaching Practice? Results from a Three-Year Study,” October 2000, https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED455227.
  54. Jonathan A. Supovitz and Herbert M. Turner, “The Effects of Professional Development on Science Teaching Practices and Classroom Culture,” Journal of Research in Science Teaching 37, no. 9 (2000): 963–80.
  55. Linda Darling-Hammond, Maria E. Hyler, and Madelyn Gardner, “Effective Teacher Professional Development,” Learning Policy Institute, June 5, 2017, https://learningpolicyinstitute.org/product/ effective-teacher-professional-development-report.

Bibliography

Acree, Lauren. “Seven Lessons Learned from Implementing Micro-credentials.” NC State University. 2016, https://fi.ncsu.edu/news/seven-lessons-learned-from-implementing-micro-credentials/.

Association of College and Research Libraries (ACRL). Framework for Information Literacy for Higher Education. 2016. https://www.ala.org/acrl/standards/ilframework.

Association of College & Research Libraries. https://www.ala.org/acrl/.

Albitz, Rebecca S. “The What and Who of Information Literacy and Critical Thinking in Higher Education.” portal: Libraries and the Academy 7, no. 1 (2007): 97–109.

Becksford, Lisa. “Instruction Librarians’ Perceptions of the Faculty–Librarian Relationship.”

Communications in Information Literacy 16(2) (2022).

Bowles-Terry, Melissa, and Karen Sobel. “Librarians as Faculty Developers: Competencies and Recommendations.” The Journal of Academic Librarianship 48, no. 1 (2022): 102474.

Darling-Hammond, Linda, Maria E. Hyler, and Madelyn Gardner. “Effective Teacher Professional Development.” Learning Policy Institute. June 5, 2017. https://learningpolicyinstitute.org/product/ effective-teacher-professional-development-report.

Douglas, Veronica Arellano, and Celia E. Rabinowitz. “Examining the Relationship Between Faculty-Librarian Collaboration and First-Year Students’ Information Literacy Abilities.” College & Research Libraries 77, no. 2 (2016): 144–63.

Fabros, Bench G., and Edwin D. Ibañez. “Effectiveness of Utilizing Graphic Organizers in Improving Conceptual Understanding towards Operations of Fractions among Teachers.” International Journal of Instruction 16, no. 1 (2023).

Fagan, Jody Condit, Hillary Ostermiller, Elizabeth Price, and Lara Sapp. “Librarian, Faculty, and Student Perceptions of Academic Librarians: Study Introduction and Literature Review.” New Review of Academic Librarianship 27, no. 1 (2021): 38–75.

Fister, Barbara. “The Social Life of Knowledge.” Not Just Where to Click, 87. https://barbarafister.net/ SocialLife.pdf.

Flierl, Michael, Clarence Maybee, and Rachel Fundator. “Academic Librarians’ Experiences as Faculty Developers: A Phenomenographic Study.” Communications in Information Literacy 13, no. 2 (2019): 184–204.

Fribley, Karla, Jason M. Vance, and Justin G. Gardner. “Academic Librarians and Campus-Wide Faculty Development: A National Survey.” portal: Libraries and the Academy 21, no. 2 (2021): 253–74.

Fundator, Rachel, and Clarence Maybee. “Academic Librarians as Informed Learning Developers.” In Informed Learning Applications: Insights from Research and Practice, 81–94. Leeds, UK: Emerald Publishing Limited, 2019.

Gocsik, Karen, Laura R. Braunstein, and E. Tobery Cynthia. “Approximating the University: The Information Literacy Practices of Novice Researchers.” Information Literacy: Research and Collaboration Across Disciplines (2017): 163–84.

Goodsett, Mandi. “Assessing the Potential for Critical Thinking Instruction in Information Literacy Online Learning Objects Using Best Practices.” Communications in Information Literacy 14, no. 2 (2020): 227–54.

Green, Jennifer D., and Beth Dillard. “Scaffolding the Scaffold: Creating Graphic Organizers to Support Your Students’ Learning.” Transformative Dialogues: Teaching and Learning Journal 14, no. 2 (2021). Head, Alison. “Reading in the Age of Distrust.” Project Information Literacy. 2021. https://projectinfolit.

org/pubs/provocation-series/essays/reading-in-the-age-of-distrust.html.

Herrmann, Bailey. “Writing as an Exploration: Rethinking the Research Paper.” The Wisconsin English Journal 54, no. 2: 49–51.

Hunt, Tiffany, Richard Carter, Ling Zhang, and Sohyun Yang. “Micro-credentials: The Potential of Personalized Professional Development.” Development and Learning in Organizations: An International Journal 34, no. 2 (2020): 33–35.

Insua, Glenda, Catherine Lantz, and Annie Armstrong. “Navigating Roadblocks: First-year Writing Challenges through the Lens of the ACRL Framework.” Communications in Information Literacy 12, No. 2 (2018). https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1205064.pdf.

Kilickaya, Ferit. “Review of Studies on Graphic Organizers and Language Learner Performance.” Online Submission 23 (2019): 6–11.

McCullough, Heather, and Kim Buch. “Using Certificates to Engage Faculty in Professional Development.”

Current Issues in Education 21, no. 2 (Special Issue) (2020).

Mi, Misa. “Expanding Librarian Roles through a Librarian Initiated and Facilitated Faculty Learning Community.” Journal of Library Administration 55, no. 1 (2015): 24–40.

Nakiboğlu, Canan, and Nuri Nakiboğlu. “Views of Prospective Chemistry Teachers on the Use of Graphic Organizers Supported with Interactive PowerPoint Presentation Technology in Teaching

Electrochemistry Concepts.” International Journal of Physics and Chemistry Education 13, no. 3 (2021): 47–63.

Nalani Meulemans, Yvonne, and Allison Carr. “Not at Your Service: Building Genuine Faculty-Librarian Partnerships.” Reference Services Review 41, no. 1 (2013): 80–90.

Ng, Wan. “Can We Teach Digital Natives Digital Literacy?” Computers & Education 59, no. 3 (2012): 1065–78.

Porter, Andrew C., Michael S. Garet, Laura Desimone, Kwang Suk Yoon, and Beatrice F. Birman. “Does Professional Development Change Teaching Practice? Results from a Three-Year Study.” October 2000. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED455227.

Saunders, Laura, Jenny Severyn, and Jes Caron. “Don’t They Teach That in High School? Examining the High School to College Information Literacy Gap.” Library & Information Science Research 39, no. 4 (2017): 276–83.

SMCM Center for Inclusive Teaching and Learning. Accessed November 30, 2023. https://www.smcm.edu/ citl/.

SMCM CORE Seminars. Accessed November 30, 2023. https://www.smcm.edu/newstudents/ core-seminars/.

SMCM Hilda C. Landers Library. Accessed November 30, 2023. https://library.smcm.edu/.

SMCM LEAD Curriculum. Accessed November 30, 2023. https://www.smcm.edu/academics/lead/.

SMCM Quick Facts 2022-2023. Accessed November 30, 2023. https://www.smcm.edu/ir/about-st-marys/ quick-facts/.

SMCM Writing and Speaking Center. Handouts and Tips: Rhetorical Awareness. Accessed November 30, 2023. https://www.smcm.edu/writingcenter/handouts-and-tips/.

Sommers, Nancy, and Laura Saltz. “The Novice as Expert: Writing the Freshman Year.” College Composition and Communication (2004): 124–49.

Supovitz, Jonathan A., and Herbert M. Turner. “The Effects of Professional Development on Science Teaching Practices and Classroom Culture.” Journal of Research in Science Teaching 37, no. 9 (2000): 963–80.

Tooley, Melissa, and Joseph Hood. “Harnessing Micro-Credentials for Teacher Growth: A National Review of Early Best Practices.” New America (2021).

Tooley, Melissa, and Joseph Hood. “Moving toward Competency-Based Professional Learning.” State Education Standard 21, no. 2 (2021): 35.

Valenza, Joyce Kasman, Heather Dalal, Gihan Mohamad, Brenda Boyer, Cara Berg, Leslin H. Charles, Rebecca Bushby, Megan Dempsey, Joan Dalrymple, and Ewa Dziedzic-Elliott. “First Years’ Information Literacy Backpacks: What’s Already Packed or Not Packed?” The Journal of Academic Librarianship 48, no. 4 (2022): 102566.

Williams, Kate Z., Lauren E. Margulieux, and G. David Lawrence. “Teaching Certificate Redesign: Making a Flexible Program for Future Faculty.” To Improve the Academy: A Journal of Educational Development 39, no. 2 (2020).